What Are the States That Do Not Use Credit Scores in Auto Insurance?
Why You Can Trust EverQuote
EverQuote powers millions of shopper requests every month, teaming up with industry-leading insurance specialists to address real-world challenges faced by people every day. We partner with the largest insurance providers in the nation, and our content is carefully crafted by experts and reviewed by licensed insurance agents for accuracy and relevance.
Your credit score influences more than just your ability to secure loans and favorable interest rates. In many parts of the country, it can also play a role in determining your auto insurance premiums.
Many insurance providers consider your credit score when setting rates. However, this practice is prohibited in certain states, leading to notable differences in how premiums are calculated.
Let's take a look at the states that do not use credit scores in auto insurance and what the implications for consumers in these regions are.
Which States Prohibit the Use of Credit Scores in Auto Insurance Rates?
While most states allow insurance companies to review customer credit scores to determine auto insurance rates, a handful have taken steps to restrict or ban this practice. Some of the states banning the use of credit scores for auto insurance include:
- California: Completely prohibits the use of credit information in auto insurance pricing
- Hawaii: Bans the use of credit scores for auto insurance rates
- Massachusetts: Doesn't allow credit information to be used in auto insurance underwriting or rating
- Michigan: Recently banned the use of credit scores in auto insurance pricing as part of broader auto insurance reforms
- Maryland: While not banning credit scores outright, the state significantly restricts their use. Insurers can't use credit history to deny, cancel, or refuse to renew a policy. They also can't increase premiums based solely on credit information.
- Oregon: Doesn't ban credit scores but limits their impact. Insurers can't use credit information as the primary factor in deciding rates or whether to issue or renew a policy. They also must re-evaluate credit-based insurance scores every three years.
It's worth noting that credit score impact on auto insurance laws change, and some states that aren't on this list may have partial restrictions or are considering legislation to limit the use of credit scores in insurance pricing.
What Are the Main Reasons Behind These State Regulations?
The main reasons for pushing insurance companies to provide auto insurance rates without credit score consideration come from concerns about fairness and consumer protection. Here are some of the reasons why some states have taken action:
- Discrimination concerns: Using credit scores may cause companies to inadvertently discriminate against low-income individuals and certain minority groups that tend to have lower credit scores.
- Relevance questions: Credit scores aren't directly related to driving ability or accident risk, making their use in auto insurance pricing unfair.
- Privacy concerns: Credit information is personal and shouldn't factor into auto insurance decisions.
- Lack of transparency: The complex algorithms used to calculate insurance scores are often not fully disclosed, leading to concerns about accountability.
- Consumer protection: Some states aim to shield consumers from practices they view as potentially predatory or unfair.
Find the right coverage in your state
How Do These Bans Impact Consumers in Those States?
Preventing insurance companies from using credit scores for auto insurance pricing has a mixed impact on consumers in affected states. For many, especially those with lower credit scores, the bans can lead to more affordable insurance rates. Without credit scores factoring into pricing, individuals who might have faced higher premiums due to poor credit may see their costs decrease. The bans also shift the focus of pricing more directly to driving-related factors. This change can benefit safe drivers, regardless of their credit history, as their good driving records become more influential in determining their premiums.
However, the impact isn't universally positive. Consumers with excellent credit might lose out on discounts they previously enjoyed, potentially facing higher premiums as a result. Insurance companies may adjust their pricing strategies in response to these bans. This could lead to broader changes in the market, increasing rates across the board to offset the lost revenue from higher premiums for drivers with low credit scores.
What Are the Arguments For and Against Using Credit Scores in Auto Insurance?
Allowing insurance companies to use credit scores to determine auto insurance premiums is a hotly debated topic. Some of the top arguments for allowing insurers to use credit scores include:
- Personalized pricing: Credit-based pricing could lead to lower rates for consumers with good credit, rewarding financial responsibility.
- Objective measure: Credit scores provide a standardized, data-driven factor in pricing, potentially reducing subjective bias in underwriting.
- Incentive for financial responsibility: The practice may encourage consumers to maintain good credit, which comes with broader economic benefits.
On the other hand, there are many arguments against allowing the use of credit scores:
- Discrimination concerns: The practice disproportionately affects low-income individuals.
- Irrelevance to driving: Credit scores don't directly reflect driving ability or accident risk.
- Privacy issues: Using credit information for insurance pricing may be an invasion of privacy.
- Compounding financial hardship: Those struggling financially may face higher insurance costs, exacerbating their economic challenges.
- Lack of transparency: The complex algorithms used to calculate insurance scores are often not fully disclosed, leading to accountability concerns.
- External factors: Life events like medical emergencies or job loss can impact credit scores, unfairly affecting insurance rates.
How Do Insurance Companies Adapt to These Regulations?
Insurance companies have to get creative in states that ban the use of credit scores for auto insurance pricing. Since credit score can no longer impact auto insurance premiums in these states, insurance companies have had to look at other factors to determine auto premiums. For example, insurance companies may focus on risk factors like driving history, age, and the type of car you drive.
These changes often require insurers to significantly overhaul their pricing models and data analytics systems. Insurers must update their algorithms and pricing tools to help them assess risk accurately without relying on credit information. They also offer alternative ways for drivers to obtain a discount on their auto insurance, such as through safe driver discounts, low mileage discounts, or defensive driver courses.
Ultimately, insurance companies need to comply with these new regulations while still maintaining accurate risk assessment and competitive pricing. If you're concerned about how your credit might be affecting your auto insurance rates, check with your state's insurance department for the most up-to-date information. Remember, even in states where it's allowed, credit scores are just one of many factors insurers use to set rates.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does bad credit impact my insurance premium?
What is a good credit score range for affordable auto insurance?
How much will I save switching insurance providers?
Premiums are sourced from over 30,000 zip codes across 200 insurance companies. We estimate premiums based on public filings for policies seeking 50/100 in liability with $500 deductibles for collision and comprehensive coverage. Estimated rates are based on a 35-year-old single female with a good credit score and no history of accidents or violations driving a 2023 Toyota RAV4 LE. We partner with Quadrant Information Services to source our data and assume no unique benefits or discounts are applied for these rates (unless otherwise stated). Your own rates may be different.