List of Car Insurance Companies

Posted April 10th, 2019 by EverQuote Staff

There are dozens of auto insurance companies in the U.S., so you have many choices when you want to buy car insurance. Below is a list of car insurance companies in the top 50 for market share, with websites and the location of headquarters. Remember that not all auto insurance companies operate in every state.

List of car insurance companies

Rank Company
Click to see company reviews
Website Headquarters
1 State Farm Bloomington, IL
2 Progressive Mayfield, OH
3 Allstate Corp. Northbrook, IL
4 USAA San Antonio, TX
5 Liberty Mutual Boston, MA
6 Farmers Insurance Group Woodland Hills, CA
7 Nationwide Columbus, OH
8 American Family Insurance Group Madison, WI
9 Travelers Saint Paul, MN
10 Auto Club Exchange (AAA Insurance) Costa Mesa, CA
11 Erie Insurance Erie, PA
12 Kemper Chicago, IL
13 National General Holdings Corp New York, NY
14 CSAA Insurance Exchange Walnut Creek, CA
15 Auto-Owners Insurance Lansing, MI
16 Mercury Insurance Los Angeles, CA
17 MetLife New York, NY
18 The Hartford Hartford, CT
19 Auto Club Insurance Association Dearborn, MI
20 Amica Lincoln, RI
21 The Hanover Insurance Group Worcester, MA
22 COUNTRY Financial Bloomington, IL
23 NJM Insurance West Trenton, NJ
24 Southern Farm Bureau Casualty Ridgeland, MS
25 Sentry Stevens Point, WI
26 Shelter Insurance Columbia, MO
27 Alfa Mutual Group Montgomery, AL
28 Ameriprise Financial Minneapolis, MN
29 Chubb Whitehouse Station, NJ
30 Texas Farm Bureau Insurance Waco, TX
31 Tennessee Farmers Insurance Cos. Columbia, TN
32 Plymouth Rock of New Jersey Red Bank, NJ
33 The Cincinnati Insurance Cos. Fairfield, OH
34 North Carolina Farm Bureau Insurance Raleigh, NC
35 Kentucky Farm Bureau Louisville, KY
36 State Auto Columbus, OH
37 Consumers County Mutual Insurance Co. Now an underwriter for Texas customers of American Modern Insurance Dallas, TX
38 Grange Insurance Columbus, OH
39 American National Galveston, TX
40 Loya Insurance El Paso, TX
41 Farm Bureau Financial Services West Des Moines, IA
42 Safety Insurance Boston, MA
43 Wawanesa General Insurance Co. San Diego, CA
44 Horace Mann Springfield, IL
45 Markel Glen Allen, VA
46 Michigan Farm Bureau Lansing, MI
47 Plymouth Rock Co. Boston, MA
48 Home State Insurance Group Waco, TX
49 American Access Casualty Co. Downers Grove, IL
Source: S&P Global Market Intelligence, based on market share in 2018 for private passenger auto insurance